-
Message Boards
Movie Soundtracks
LOTR Package Update (Page 25)Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
This topic is 27 pages long: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27Author
Topic: LOTR Package Update
Christian Kühn
Standard Userer
Hm, the price's just been upped to 49€.I doubt that's the final word on it, but I just pre-ordered it, just in case!
CK
posted 09-21-2007 06:36 PM PT (US) Cavalier_of_Palahndtüs
Standard Userer
BattleToTheEnd is right: The Fourth Age of Gondor. Not Realm of Gondor/White Tree and not Into the West theme. Doug has clearly told us it's The Fourth Age of Gondor theme.
posted 09-22-2007 11:33 AM PT (US) BattleToTheEnd
Standard Userer
quote:
Originally posted by Cavalier_of_Palahndtüs:
BattleToTheEnd is right: The Fourth Age of Gondor. Not Realm of Gondor/White Tree and not Into the West theme. Doug has clearly told us it's The Fourth Age of Gondor theme.Thanks for helping clear that up Nate, and by the way just call me Andrew (note to all)
posted 09-22-2007 12:12 PM PT (US) Earl
Standard Userer
'Tis so quiet...
posted 09-23-2007 09:53 AM PT (US) ilovehobbits
Non-Standard Userer
"It's the deep breath before the plunge."
posted 09-23-2007 12:43 PM PT (US) gkgyver
Standard Userer
That's roughly the tenth time someone said this before the release.
posted 09-23-2007 01:56 PM PT (US) ilovehobbits
Non-Standard Userer
It's happened before, and it'll happen again... (hopefully)
posted 09-23-2007 03:24 PM PT (US) BattleToTheEnd
Standard Userer
Doug told me was going to come back after the 19th but I don't seem to see him anywhere within this crowd. Maybe hes building our want for juicy information to make us salivate everywhere.[Message edited by BattleToTheEnd on 09-23-2007]
posted 09-23-2007 04:22 PM PT (US) franz_conrad
Standard Userer
quote:
Originally posted by Cavalier_of_Palahndtüs:
BattleToTheEnd is right: The Fourth Age of Gondor. Not Realm of Gondor/White Tree and not Into the West theme. Doug has clearly told us it's The Fourth Age of Gondor theme.Wouldn't it be the Fourth Age of Middle Earth? (Since Gondor wasn't around for the First Age (or 90% of the second) ?)
posted 09-23-2007 04:47 PM PT (US) BattleToTheEnd
Standard Userer
No, Doug has said that it is the Fourth
Age of Gondor theme played here in this scene (I believe he said a while back though).
posted 09-23-2007 05:51 PM PT (US) Doug Adams
Standard Userer
quote:
Originally posted by BattleToTheEnd:
No, Doug has said that it is the Fourth
Age of Gondor theme played here in this scene (I believe he said a while back though).It is Gondor's Fourth Age theme... which is *slightly* different than the Fourth Age of Gondor. In fact, it's Gondor Reborn.
I may have used the wrong terminology in the past--don't remember. The whole concept of Fourth Age themes will become clearer in the near future, I promise.
I'll try to address some questions tomorrow (and get to some emails)... have been on a self-imposed exile finishing the ROTK Annotated Score.
Best,
-Doug
posted 09-23-2007 08:56 PM PT (US) Timdalf
Standard Userer
>>>Originally posted by Doug Adams:It is Gondor's Fourth Age theme... which is *slightly* different than the Fourth Age of Gondor. In fact, it's Gondor Reborn.
I may have used the wrong terminology in the past--don't remember. The whole concept of Fourth Age themes will become clearer in the near future, I promise.
I'll try to address some questions tomorrow (and get to some emails)... have been on a self-imposed exile finishing the ROTK Annotated Score.
Best,
-Doug<<<In other words, Gondor in the Fourth Age... since the Fourth Age is the Age of Men (or at least the first of them).
Good to know we can now look forward at last to the Return of Doug Adagorn from (self-imposed) exile...
Hmmm, now where DID I put that crown???...I'll have to ask Shoredalf, he is the real wizard in these parts!! ;-)
Timdalf
posted 09-24-2007 07:03 AM PT (US) Earl
Standard Userer
The press realease didn't say anything about the booklet, and Doug, I'm assuming you can't say anything either, but mayhap you could deviously propose whether it will (or will not) be the same as its predecessors?I'm just asking since I'm worried about pricing and if you can't say anything yet, please ignore this post.
[Message edited by Earl on 09-24-2007]
posted 09-24-2007 07:24 AM PT (US) Ge0rge
Standard Userer
HS talks about Doug, book, not all music included into CRs, the Symphony etc.! http://www.blogtalkradio.com/moviegeeksunited
posted 09-24-2007 09:02 AM PT (US) gkgyver
Standard Userer
Won't play for me.
posted 09-24-2007 09:27 AM PT (US) Christian Kühn
Standard Userer
quote:
Doug Adagorn
ShoredalfEh...not very witty, sorry mate!
...
Although, I made some fun of Doug setting the Nazgûl on me, so I guess it's fair game. Would be bad if German sense of humour (we have one? Georg?) would set the standard on this Board, no?
"Four hobbits walked into a bar. What did they say?"
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
."Ouch!"
Oh come on, that was funny!
CK
posted 09-24-2007 09:41 AM PT (US) Cavalier_of_Palahndtüs
Standard Userer
I don't get it, CK...?
posted 09-24-2007 03:16 PM PT (US) BattleToTheEnd
Standard Userer
quote:
Originally posted by Cavalier_of_Palahndtüs:
I don't get it, CK...?I don't either.........
posted 09-24-2007 03:47 PM PT (US) Timdalf
Standard Userer
>>>Originally posted by Christian Kühn:Eh...not very witty, sorry mate!
Although, I made some fun of Doug setting the Nazgûl on me, so I guess it's fair game.
"Four hobbits walked into a bar. What did they say?"
"Ouch!"
Oh come on, that was funny!
CK<<<
"Not very witty, sorry mate!" ;-)
PS: I intended nothing but to pay Doug and Maestro Shore a sincere and respectful compliment!!!
posted 09-24-2007 04:46 PM PT (US) Magpie
Standard Userer
Well, I have to say that I got Christian's joke and I thought it was funny.posted 09-24-2007 06:50 PM PT (US) BattleToTheEnd
Standard Userer
Please tell me, what does the joke mean? Magpie! CK! Come on now don't hold out.
posted 09-24-2007 07:08 PM PT (US) gkgyver
Standard Userer
I got it, but I'm too tired to explain it ...Please don't take it as a textbook example of German wit
posted 09-24-2007 07:49 PM PT (US) Wedge
Standard Userer
It's a variation on an old joke. As in, "Two hunters walked into a bar. The third one ducked."
posted 09-24-2007 08:02 PM PT (US) BattleToTheEnd
Standard Userer
Alright I got it now, I guess I should transfer to a better college, perhaps one that can actually teach me to where I can understand something like this joke. But now I gotta go since I decided to take a job that requires me to be awake at 4:30 A.M. (Woopdy freaking doo, can't wait).[Message edited by BattleToTheEnd on 09-24-2007]
posted 09-24-2007 08:11 PM PT (US) *Tom*
Non-Standard Userer
If people are having issues with the Howard Shore 'Movie Geeks United' interview, you can download it off itunes.Just search for the 'Movie Geeks United' podcast.
The HS interview is the latest episode
posted 09-25-2007 01:25 AM PT (US) Christian Kühn
Standard Userer
My apologies, everyone!I was a bit off colour yesterday evening and brought a bit of my bad mood onto this forum.
Christian
posted 09-25-2007 06:53 AM PT (US) Doug Adams
Standard Userer
Hi everyone,My self-imposed exile is up, so I’ll try to add a few tidbits, updates, etc.
The first draft of the Annotated Score is now done (hence the exile). Editing and revisions will be coming soon!
Just to stave off any uncontrolled rumor mongering, there will no box-set of alternates. There a ton of stuff, to be sure, but that’s not how it’ll be presented. (And it will be presented, fear not!) And as for the 4 hours comment re: ROTK’s score, yes, this is taking into account alternates and unused pieces that were written, like the ride to Minas Tirith with alternate percussion or Frodo’s Song, etc., etc., etc. Honestly, 4.5 hours is probably a low figure when you take that ALL into account… but remember many alternates are only slightly different. If triangle plays once in the film and three times in the alternate, is that really an entirely different piece of music? If there’s a piece that sets English horn playing the History of the Ring over aleatoric strings, do we also want to hear the take where the English horn didn’t play? Is it interesting enough to even count? These are, incidentally, the same considerations being taken into account for the final presentation of this unused material. What’s really worth hearing? I know there are those that’ll say, “Everything, gimme it all!” But besides the fact that this isn’t physically feasible, there’s really only so much your ear can take it before it becomes dulled by repetition. I mean, we could fill an entire CD with just unused Prologue material from Fellowship… actually, that’s a bad example—that stuff is amazingly interesting!
Hard numbers are always going to be pretty useless in this arena, so 4 to 4.5 hours is/was a good ballpark figure, nothing more.
I won’t say much more about the presentation of unused material for now, save to say that there is a plan in place… and if you scour other posts, you’ll get some pretty good hints. Heck, I think I even buried the proposed release date in there somewhere. Dig deep!
Contracts are being drawn up now, so once everything is nice and legal, I’ll be happy to spill a few more beans.
Anyway, as you know, the four CDs and 1 DVD of ROTK:CR will solely contain ROTK music. Like the other boxed sets, ROTK will *essentially* present Shore’s final drafts of his compositions, including music that that was replaced in the film with sound effects, silence, etc. There are a few exceptions to that rule, same as there were on FOTR and TTT.
>>>And does this mean we get Sissle's piece as well??>>>
You will get Sissel’s piece, yep! Liv’s too. It will all make sense when you see the track list.
>>>Great news, everyone! Doug, have you heard the final mix for the 'end of all things' piece in CR? I'm afraid to find out the choir mixed not that powerful as in the OST, as it was done in the FOTR CR...>>>
The chorus is loud and proud.
>>>A blood red or a deep burgandy slip case with gold leaf lettering would be quite nice. Of course it would need to be big enough to fit the rarities discs as well. I wonder if the rarities discs will come in their own boxed set and what color that will be?>>>
I will be heavily involved with the Rarities production, but it’s a little ways off. You’ll see, you’ll see. (I know, it seems like each secret revealed simply unearths a dozen more. Sorry! I promise to say more when it’s time.)
*****
1. The Finding Of The One Ring
2. The Days Are Growing Darker
3. Flotsam And Jetsam
4. Return To Edoras
5. Gollum's Villainy
6. The Palantir
7. Hope And Memory (I realise it's unlikely, but it's a beautiful title for this music)
8. The White Tower
9. Denethor
10. The Glory Of Gondor
11. Journey To The Crossroads
12. The Dead City
13. Osgiliath Overrun
14. Amon Din
15. For Lord And Land
16. Denethor And Faramir
17. The Stairs Of Cirith Ungol
18. Gollum's Treachery
19. The Last Son
20. Dunharrow
21. The Flame Of The West
22. The Dawn Of Battle
23. The Dimholt
24. Ride For Gondor!
25. The Paths Of The Dead
26. Denethor's Madness
27. The Siege Of Gondor
28. The Corsairs Of Umbar
29. Shelob's Lair
30. The Choices Of Master Samwise
31. The Second Level Burns
32. The Horns Of Rohan
33. Denethor's Pyre
34. The Pelennor Fields
35. The Nazgul And His Prey
36. Requiem For Theoden
37. The Houses Of Healing
38. The Tower Of Cirith Ungol
39. The Last Debate
40. The Land Of Shadow
41. The Black Gate Opens
42. For Frodo
43. The Destruction Of The Ring
44. The Destruction Of Mordor
45. Many Partings
46. A Far Green Country
47. Epilogue
48. The End Of An Age
*****I’m happy to tell you, you’ve got seven correct track titles in here!
>>>Can anyone tell me how soon they released the track titles and annotated score for the previous releases? This wait is going to be unbearable!>>>
>>>I think the Annotated Score came out after the release of the CDs? Am I remembering correctly? I thought it was within a week or two, but I remember waiting anxiously and I wouldn't have been 'anxious' before the CDs came out.>>>
The Annotated Score did, indeed, come out along with the CDs… or perhaps a day later. We’re in a better place, schedule-wise, this year, so I’d imaging you’ll see the website updated on the release day.
That’s all for today, folks. Back soon!
-Doug
PS – Oh hey, I meant to ask… Are you guys interested in another FSM Podcast ROTK preview this year? If so, what format? Are you out of questions by now, or are there enough to fill another podcast? Thoughts?
posted 09-25-2007 09:56 AM PT (US) Earl
Standard Userer
Oh Doug, glad you're back. And glad to hear the great updates as well. And also glad to hear you'll be deeply involved with the rarities stuff. Not as glad to hear it won't be a boxed set, but glad to assume this means it'll be released along with your book.Thanks for a great update as usual and YES, I at least hope you'll be up for an ROTK podcast since it'll be some time before I get the CR itself (and I'm counting on the podcast music to tide me over 'til the CR's mine).
posted 09-25-2007 10:47 AM PT (US) Christian Kühn
Standard Userer
N/A[Message edited by Christian Kühn on 09-25-2007]
posted 09-25-2007 12:50 PM PT (US) Christian Kühn
Standard Userer
quote:
Originally posted by Doug Adams:
Hi everyone,My self-imposed exile is up, so I’ll try to add a few tidbits, updates, etc.
The first draft of the Annotated Score is now done (hence the exile). Editing and revisions will be coming soon!
Greatly looking forward to it, Doug. And your usage of little-known English words. Out of curiosity: FotR's AS was 29 pages long (1,1 MB), the one for T2T 41 (6 MB). Apart from the instruments' section and the choral lyrics (which don't differ that much in length), was there so much more to write about T2T? Will you be aiming at a similar length (proportionate to the score's length, of course) for RotK?
(And will we get a small thank you section for ourselves? In very small font? )
quote:
What’s really worth hearing? I know there are those that’ll say, “Everything, gimme it all!”As long as "not everything" includes the NZSO version of 'The Breaking of the Fellowship', I'm content. I know, it's available for ripping from the Fan Credits, but there's something about having it in excellent sound quality on a a pressed CD that would make it worth including. That is, if I had something to say in those matters.
quote:
But besides the fact that this isn’t physically feasible, there’s really only so much your ear can take it before it becomes dulled by repetition.This is not Horner we're talking about here... (ducks to avoid anvils being thrown my way)
quote:
I mean, we could fill an entire CD with just unused Prologue material from Fellowship… actually, that’s a bad example—that stuff is amazingly interesting!I repeat: !
quote:
Heck, I think I even buried the proposed release date in there somewhere. Dig deep!*runs off and digs* Ah! *runs back* Cool!
quote:
Anyway, as you know, the four CDs and 1 DVD of ROTK:CR will solely contain ROTK music.Why should/would it be otherwise? I'm confused.
quote:
You will get Sissel’s piece, yep! Liv’s too. It will all make sense when you see the track list.Cool!
quote:
The chorus is loud and proud.Must. Contain. Myself. I sense scoregasms extraordinaire down the way.
This time, I guess I'll set up my digicam when I first listen to this set...to show you all what a correct scoregasm should look like.
quote:
I will be heavily involved with the Rarities production, but it’s a little ways off. You’ll see, you’ll see. (I know, it seems like each secret revealed simply unearths a dozen more. Sorry! I promise to say more when it’s time.)You know, I'm gonna miss these times once everything's said and done and you have nothing either to be secretive about or to reveal!
quote:
That’s all for today, folks. Back soon!-Doug
PS – Oh hey, I meant to ask… Are you guys interested in another FSM Podcast ROTK preview this year? If so, what format? Are you out of questions by now, or are there enough to fill another podcast? Thoughts?
You should know by now that we *never* run out of questions. Can we all send in video-taped questions? Or make a huge conference call?
All Best, Doug, and scratch up another pint for you (gee, that bill will be horrible!).
Christian
posted 09-25-2007 12:57 PM PT (US) Beren
Standard Userer
Thanks for the update DA.And i'm actually glad that the rarities disc(s) won't come in a box-set, having so a low price(hopefully and logically).Q:Will there be,at the end(the end meaning just a few months away, right? ), more than 11 hours of music on discs?
posted 09-25-2007 01:42 PM PT (US) musicfan008
Non-Standard Userer
Anyone know if the complete recordings will include the singing from Merry and Pippen at the feast in the original movie and the orcs chanting Grond as they are marching toward Minis Tirith.
posted 09-25-2007 02:09 PM PT (US) gkgyver
Standard Userer
quote:
CAST PERFORMERS
Billy Boyd
Dominic Monaghan
Viggo Mortensen
Liv TylerIt doesn't list an army of Orcs, so I'd say no
That falls under the same category as the Rohan horns that some think would actually improve the scene.
Sound effects don't belong onto such a release.And Doug, by now you should know that we wouldn't even be against five podcasts
And I'm pretty sure Doug implied that the suggested release date for book/rarities was fall 2008."Maybe Santa can help you with all the above ..."
You sneaky little hobbit!posted 09-25-2007 02:20 PM PT (US) Christian Kühn
Standard Userer
quote:
Originally posted by musicfan008:
Anyone know if the complete recordings will include the singing from Merry and Pippen at the feast in the original movie and the orcs chanting Grond as they are marching toward Minis Tirith.Positive for the former and GOD FORBID on the latter.
CK
posted 09-25-2007 02:23 PM PT (US) Magpie
Standard Userer
ha... funny thing about the Grond chanting. I actually pulled a soundclip of this a while back. If you listen to the chanting, you'd expect to hear a mass voice with no one voice standing out in the chanting. And that's what it sounds like at the end of the clip. But at the beginning (and this might be in the middle of the chanting in the movie. Can't remember if I cut stuff off at the beginning) you can hear quite distinct voices almost over enunciating, especially the final 'd'. I wondered if some people got their voices mixed in as a lark so that it would be recognizable if pointed out and overlooked if not. The clip is here: http://www.geocities.com/magpie930/temp_sound_clips/grond.z
It's a zip file that forces you to download it onto your harddrive where you can listen to it as much as you want w/o driving up my bandwidth. (also foils hotlinking)
posted 09-25-2007 03:38 PM PT (US) ruckus
Non-Standard Userer
Thanks for the update Doug. I just wanted to add my support for a podcast. I probably won't be able to get the CR until Christmas so, like Earl, I'll welcome even the shortest snippets. I enjoyed the Q&A format of the last podcast - so that would be great.ruckus
posted 09-25-2007 05:00 PM PT (US) Olorin
Standard Userer
Thanks Doug, for the update! We are so blessed, not only in getting these CRs of extraordinary symphonic soundtrack music in this era where "soundtrack" usually means forgettable pop dreck (and yes, Christian, it means the same in English as it does in German--we have appropriated a few of your country's words :-) ), but also in having you as a contributor to this forum to answer questions and give us tantalizing tips. I might almost call you a "tease" for some of the things you said in your post, but considering how good you are to us, I think you're entitled to tease us a bit.[Message edited by Olorin on 09-25-2007]
posted 09-25-2007 05:44 PM PT (US) Christian Kühn
Standard Userer
How about all of us getting Doug a pint? I don't wanna be stranded with the bill all by myself...CK, off to bed because he's getting evil glares
posted 09-25-2007 06:14 PM PT (US) vdemona
Standard Userer
>>Are you guys interested in another FSM Podcast ROTK preview this year? If so, what format? Are you out of questions by now, or are there enough to fill another podcast? Thoughts?<<Thank you Doug!
I'd love to hear another podcast! It's been a long dry spell. Most of my questions (so far) have been answered but hearing any extra insight/info/opinions I haven't anticipated in a new podcast episode would be great!posted 09-25-2007 06:45 PM PT (US) MJC
Standard Userer
Thanks for the great news Doug. Yep would love to hear another podcast on it. Can't wait to hear it.Martin
posted 09-25-2007 08:20 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB